Benefit fraud investigations often begin with a letter inviting you to an interview, or a request for information about your circumstances, work or household. Many people under investigation did not realise they had to report a change, misunderstood a form, or were affected by illness or stress at the time. The way the investigation is handled at the start can make the difference between an overpayment being recovered and a criminal prosecution.
Our benefit fraud solicitors in Glasgow advise on investigations by the Department for Work and Pensions and Social Security Scotland, and defend people who are prosecuted.
Key points
- Reserved benefits, such as Universal Credit, are run by the Department for Work and Pensions. Devolved benefits, such as Adult Disability Payment, are run by Social Security Scotland.
- Dishonestly making a false statement to obtain a DWP benefit is an offence under section 111A of the Social Security Administration Act 1992, with up to 7 years in prison on indictment.
- The Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018 contains its own offence of trying to obtain assistance by deceit.
- Benefit fraud can also be prosecuted as common law fraud.
In police custody now? Ask for a solicitor straight away. Advice while you are in police custody is free, and the police must arrange it, either from your own solicitor or a duty solicitor. Our enquiry form is not monitored around the clock, so do not wait to hear from us before asking for advice at the station.
Interviews under caution
If you are invited to an interview under caution about your benefits, it is a formal criminal interview, and what you say can be used as evidence. You have the right to legal advice before and during it. Do not attend without taking advice first. We can find out what the investigation is about, review your claim history with you and help you decide how to respond. See also police interview advice.
Overpayment or prosecution?
Not every overpayment is a crime. Where the benefit agency decides you were paid too much, it can recover the money through deductions or repayment arrangements without any prosecution. A prosecution requires dishonesty, or in some cases a failure to report a change that you knew you had to report. Showing that a mistake was genuine, and that you co-operated, can make a prosecution less likely. Where a case is reported, the procurator fiscal decides whether to prosecute.
Defending a benefit fraud charge
- No dishonesty. Misunderstanding the rules, confusing forms or illness affecting your ability to report changes are not dishonesty.
- What you were told. Advice from the agency or from others about what to report can be important evidence.
- The overpayment figure. Calculations are often wrong or overstated, for example by ignoring benefits you would have received anyway.
- Household evidence. Living together allegations are common and depend on detailed evidence that can be challenged.
Penalties
Outcomes depend mainly on the amount, the length of time and whether there was dishonesty. Many cases are dealt with by repayment, a fine or a community sentence. Larger or long-running frauds can lead to prison, and confiscation under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 is possible.
Criminal defence fees
We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.
Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.
Book a free consultation

