Criminal defence

Culpable Homicide Lawyer Glasgow

Facing a culpable homicide charge, or a murder charge where culpable homicide may be the real issue? Our lawyers in Glasgow understand the distinctions that decide these cases.

A defence solicitor reading an expert report at his desk

Culpable homicide is the Scots law crime of causing someone's death in circumstances that do not amount to murder. It can arise from a single punch, a fight that ended tragically, a death at work, or a killing where the accused's responsibility was reduced. It is also a common alternative verdict in murder trials.

Our culpable homicide lawyers in Glasgow prepare these cases in detail, with independent experts and experienced counsel.

Key points

  • Culpable homicide is a common law crime covering unlawful killings that are not murder.
  • "Voluntary" culpable homicide applies where a killing would be murder but for provocation or diminished responsibility.
  • "Involuntary" culpable homicide covers deaths caused by an unlawful act, such as an assault, or by gross recklessness, without the intent required for murder.
  • There is no fixed sentence, so mitigation and the circumstances of the death are critical.

In police custody now? Ask for a solicitor straight away. Advice while you are in police custody is free, and the police must arrange it, either from your own solicitor or a duty solicitor. Our enquiry form is not monitored around the clock, so do not wait to hear from us before asking for advice at the station.

Types of culpable homicide

Voluntary culpable homicide

Where the accused would otherwise be guilty of murder, the conviction is for culpable homicide instead if provocation or diminished responsibility is established. Under the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995, diminished responsibility applies where the accused's ability to determine or control their conduct was substantially impaired by an abnormality of mind, including mental disorder. Intoxication alone does not count, and the accused must establish the condition on the balance of probabilities.

Involuntary culpable homicide

Where there was no intention to kill and no wicked recklessness, a death can still be culpable homicide if it was caused by an unlawful act directed at the person, such as an assault, or by a lawful act carried out with gross recklessness. Single punch cases, where a victim falls and suffers a fatal head injury, are often charged in this way.

Defending a culpable homicide charge

  • Causation. We test, with independent pathology evidence, whether the accused's actions actually caused the death.
  • Self-defence. Self-defence can be a complete defence where its requirements are met.
  • No unlawful act or recklessness. An accident, without an unlawful act or gross recklessness, is not culpable homicide.
  • Psychiatric evidence. Where diminished responsibility is relevant, we instruct experienced psychiatrists early.

Sentence

Unlike murder, culpable homicide has no fixed sentence. Outcomes vary widely depending on the circumstances, from long prison sentences to, in exceptional cases, non-custodial disposals. Thorough preparation of mitigation, including reports about the accused's background and remorse, can make a significant difference.

Criminal defence fees

We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.

Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.

Book a free consultation
Frequently asked questions

Culpable Homicide Lawyer Glasgow: your questions answered

If your question is not here, ask us at your free 1 hour consultation.

Ask us a question
What is culpable homicide in Scotland?

It is the crime of causing a death unlawfully in circumstances that do not amount to murder, for example where there was no intention to kill or where diminished responsibility or provocation applies.

Is culpable homicide the same as manslaughter?

It is broadly the Scottish equivalent of manslaughter in England, but the law has developed separately and the details differ.

What is the sentence for culpable homicide?

There is no fixed sentence. The court can impose anything up to life imprisonment, depending on the circumstances and mitigation.

What is diminished responsibility?

Where the accused's ability to determine or control their conduct was substantially impaired by an abnormality of mind, a killing that would be murder becomes culpable homicide. The accused must prove this on the balance of probabilities.

Can a single punch lead to a culpable homicide charge?

Yes. If an assault causes a death, even without any intention to kill, the Crown may charge culpable homicide.

The Stewart Gordon Thomson team

Real people in Glasgow, in your corner

Our directors have 76 years of combined experience in legal services. We will make sure your case runs smoothly, with regular updates, so you always know where you stand.

  • Free 1 hour callwith one of our lawyers
  • Plain-English adviceon Scots law, without jargon
  • Regular updatesat every stage of your case
Meet the team
The Stewart Gordon Thomson Law Firm team
Book your free consultation