
It is very common for a partner or former partner to tell the police, or the accused, that they no longer want a domestic abuse case to go ahead. Many people assume that ends the matter. In Scotland, it does not.
The complainer cannot drop the charge. Only the procurator fiscal decides whether a prosecution continues, and in domestic abuse cases there is a strong presumption in favour of prosecuting where there is enough evidence. A case can carry on even if the complainer no longer supports it.
Key points
- Criminal charges are brought by the Crown, not by the complainer, so a complainer cannot drop them.
- The fiscal will consider the complainer's wishes, but they are not the deciding factor.
- A complainer can be cited as a witness and required to attend court.
- The case may proceed on other evidence, such as 999 calls, body worn video, injuries or other witnesses.
- Bail conditions stay in force until the court changes them, even if both of you want contact.
Why the complainer cannot drop the charges
In Scotland, prosecutions are brought in the public interest by the procurator fiscal on behalf of the Crown. The person who reported the incident is a witness, not a party to the case. Police Scotland and the Crown Office follow a joint approach to domestic abuse, which treats it seriously and generally favours prosecution where the evidence is sufficient.
Part of the reason is that pressure, fear or reconciliation can lead people to withdraw support, and the law is designed so that the decision does not rest on the complainer's shoulders.
What happens when a complainer wants to withdraw?
- They tell the police or the fiscal The complainer may give a further statement or contact the Crown Office's Victim Information and Advice service.
- The fiscal reviews the case The fiscal considers the reasons, the remaining evidence and the risk to the complainer and any children.
- A decision is made The case may continue, be reduced, or be discontinued if there is no longer enough evidence or a prosecution is no longer in the public interest.
Even where the case continues, the complainer may still be cited to give evidence. A witness who ignores a citation can be arrested on a warrant.
Can the case go ahead without the complainer's evidence?
Sometimes, yes. The Crown needs sufficient evidence in law, but that does not always have to come from the complainer. Depending on the case, it may include:
- recordings of 999 calls made at the time;
- body worn video from attending officers;
- evidence of injuries or damage;
- neighbours or other witnesses;
- messages, call logs or social media posts;
- anything said by the accused, including in a police interview.
Whether that evidence is enough, and whether it is admissible, is often where a defence is won or lost. Our domestic abuse lawyers scrutinise this material closely.
What about bail conditions?
If the accused has been released on bail, there will usually be special conditions not to contact or approach the complainer, or go to their home. Those conditions stay in force until the court varies them, even if the complainer wants contact or has withdrawn their statement.
Breaching bail is a separate offence, and contact initiated by the complainer is not a defence in itself. If both of you want the conditions changed, a solicitor can apply to the court to vary them. See our pages on bail and breach of bail conditions.
Good to know: If you are accused, never ask the complainer to withdraw their statement or change their evidence. That can lead to further serious charges, such as attempting to pervert the course of justice.
What should the accused do?
Take advice as early as possible. A solicitor can obtain the evidence, assess whether the case is strong enough without the complainer, make representations to the fiscal, and apply to vary bail where appropriate. Most domestic cases call in the sheriff court or the justice of the peace court, and the Glasgow Sheriff Court has a dedicated domestic abuse court.
Charged with a domestic offence? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. Your first hour is free.
Book a free consultationFrequently asked questions
Can the complainer write a letter asking for the case to be dropped?
They can tell the fiscal their views, and the fiscal will take them into account, but the decision remains with the fiscal.
Will the complainer get into trouble for withdrawing?
Not for changing their mind about supporting a prosecution. Different issues can arise if someone says their original statement was false, so a complainer in that position should get independent legal advice.
Can we live together while the case is ongoing?
Not if bail conditions prevent contact or going to the address. A solicitor can ask the court to vary the conditions, and you must follow them unless and until they are changed.
What happens if the complainer does not turn up at the trial?
The court may grant a warrant for the witness or adjourn the trial. If the Crown cannot proceed without that evidence, the case may be deserted or the accused acquitted.



