Criminal defence

Criminal Appeal Lawyer Scotland

Convicted and think something went wrong? Criminal appeals in Scotland have very short time limits. Our criminal appeal lawyers act quickly to protect your right to appeal.

A traditional law library with an open trial transcript

If you have been convicted and believe the trial went wrong, you may be able to appeal. But the time limits are short, sometimes just one week, and the grounds of appeal must be set out precisely. Acting quickly is essential, even if your trial was handled by another solicitor.

Our criminal appeal lawyers advise people across Scotland on appeals against conviction, working with experienced counsel in the appeal courts. For appeals against the sentence only, see sentence appeals.

Key points

  • Appeals from jury (solemn) cases go to the High Court of Justiciary sitting as an appeal court. Appeals from summary cases go to the Sheriff Appeal Court.
  • In solemn cases, you must lodge intimation of intention to appeal within 2 weeks of the final determination, then a note of appeal within 8 weeks.
  • In summary cases, an appeal against conviction is by stated case, and the application must be made within 1 week of the final determination.
  • The test is whether there has been a miscarriage of justice, and leave to appeal is needed before a full hearing.

Grounds for a conviction appeal

An appeal must show that there was a miscarriage of justice. Common grounds include:

  • the judge misdirected the jury on the law;
  • evidence was wrongly admitted or excluded;
  • the verdict was one no reasonable jury could have returned on the evidence;
  • there is fresh evidence that was not available at trial and has a reasonable explanation for that;
  • the defence was not properly presented, in a way that deprived you of a fair trial;
  • a procedural irregularity affected the fairness of the trial.

Disagreeing with the verdict is not enough. The appeal must identify a specific legal error or development that made the conviction unsafe.

How appeals work

  1. Act within the time limit Contact us straight away. In summary cases, the deadline can be just one week from the end of the case.
  2. Review We obtain the papers, the charge to the jury or the sheriff's findings and, where needed, transcripts.
  3. Grounds of appeal We draft precise grounds with counsel.
  4. Leave to appeal A judge or judges consider whether the grounds are arguable. If leave is refused, it can be challenged before a larger panel.
  5. The appeal hearing Counsel presents the appeal. The court can refuse the appeal, quash the conviction, or in some cases authorise a retrial.

Late appeals and miscarriages of justice

If a time limit has passed, the court can sometimes allow a late appeal if there is a good reason. Where all appeals have been used, the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission can review a conviction and refer it back to the High Court if it believes a miscarriage of justice may have occurred.

Criminal defence fees

We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.

Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.

Book a free consultation
Frequently asked questions

Criminal Appeal Lawyer Scotland: your questions answered

If your question is not here, ask us at your free 1 hour consultation.

Ask us a question
How long do I have to appeal a conviction in Scotland?

In solemn cases, intimation of intention to appeal must be lodged within 2 weeks of the final determination, followed by a note of appeal within 8 weeks. In summary cases, an application for a stated case must be made within 1 week.

Which court hears criminal appeals?

The High Court of Justiciary hears appeals from solemn cases. The Sheriff Appeal Court hears appeals from summary cases in the sheriff court and justice of the peace court.

What is a miscarriage of justice?

It is the test for a successful appeal. It covers errors in law, unfair procedure, unreasonable verdicts and fresh evidence that undermines the conviction.

Can I appeal if my trial solicitor made mistakes?

Possibly, if the defence was conducted in a way that meant you did not receive a fair trial. The test is demanding, and you can instruct a new solicitor for the appeal.

What if I missed the deadline?

The court can allow a late appeal in some circumstances. Contact us immediately. Where appeals are exhausted, the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission may review the case.

The Stewart Gordon Thomson team

Real people in Glasgow, in your corner

Our directors have 76 years of combined experience in legal services. We will make sure your case runs smoothly, with regular updates, so you always know where you stand.

  • Free 1 hour callwith one of our lawyers
  • Plain-English adviceon Scots law, without jargon
  • Regular updatesat every stage of your case
Meet the team
The Stewart Gordon Thomson Law Firm team
Book your free consultation