Even where you accept that you are guilty, the sentence imposed can be appealed if it was excessive or wrong in principle. Sentence appeals are often decided on the papers and the reports, so the way the grounds are framed, and the mitigation presented, can decide the outcome.
Our sentence appeal solicitors advise people across Scotland, including those who were represented by another firm at sentencing.
Key points
- In solemn cases, a note of appeal against sentence alone must be lodged within 2 weeks of the sentence being passed.
- In summary cases, a note of appeal against sentence must be lodged within 1 week of the sentence.
- The appeal court can quash the sentence and substitute another. On some appeals that can include a more severe one, so careful advice is essential before appealing.
- The Crown can also appeal a sentence it considers unduly lenient.
Grounds for a sentence appeal
- the sentence was excessive for the offence and your circumstances;
- the court failed to give proper weight to mitigation, such as an early guilty plea, your background or your health;
- the court got the facts wrong, or took account of something it should not have;
- a non-custodial alternative should have been imposed;
- the sentence was outwith the court's powers, or a related order, such as a disqualification or compensation order, was wrong.
How sentence appeals work
- Urgent review We review the sentencing remarks, reports and the plea in mitigation as soon as you contact us.
- Note of appeal We lodge the note within the time limit, setting out precise grounds.
- Leave to appeal The appeal must be granted leave before it proceeds to a full hearing.
- Bail pending appeal Where appropriate, we can apply for interim liberation while the appeal is decided.
- The hearing The court considers the grounds and can uphold, reduce or substitute the sentence.
What the appeal court looks at
The appeal court does not simply ask whether it would have chosen a different sentence. It considers whether the sentence was excessive, or wrong in principle, in light of the offence, your record, the reports before the sentencing court and the mitigation presented. New information about your circumstances since sentence can sometimes be put before the court, for example about health, employment or progress on a programme. Gathering that material quickly, with the right supporting documents, strengthens the appeal.
Crown appeals
The Crown can appeal a sentence on the ground that it is unduly lenient. If the Crown appeals your sentence, you will need representation to resist it. We act for people responding to Crown appeals as well as bringing their own.
For appeals against conviction, see criminal appeals.
Criminal defence fees
We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.
Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.
Book a free consultation

