Breach of the peace is one of Scotland's best known common law crimes. It is often charged after incidents in public places, such as a disturbance in the city centre, at a football match or outside a pub. It can feel minor, but a conviction still goes on your record and may need to be disclosed to employers.
Our breach of the peace solicitors in Glasgow examine whether the conduct really meets the legal test, and whether the case can be dealt with without a conviction.
Key points
- Breach of the peace is a common law crime, defined by court decisions rather than statute.
- The conduct must be severe enough to cause genuine alarm to ordinary people and to threaten serious disturbance to the community.
- The courts have required a public element, so conduct in private is now usually charged as threatening or abusive behaviour instead.
- Many cases are suitable for a warning, a fiscal fine or another alternative to prosecution.
In police custody now? Ask for a solicitor straight away. Advice while you are in police custody is free, and the police must arrange it, either from your own solicitor or a duty solicitor. Our enquiry form is not monitored around the clock, so do not wait to hear from us before asking for advice at the station.
The legal test for breach of the peace
The High Court has made clear that breach of the peace requires conduct severe enough to cause alarm to ordinary people and to threaten serious disturbance to the community. Both parts must be present. Shouting, swearing or arguing will not always be enough. The courts have also held that there must be a public element: the conduct must have taken place in public, or had the potential to affect the public.
Because the test is demanding, the facts matter. We look at where the incident happened, who was there, how long it lasted and whether anyone was genuinely alarmed.
Common situations
- disturbances in the street or on public transport;
- incidents at or after football matches, including sectarian behaviour;
- arguments outside pubs, clubs and takeaways;
- protests and demonstrations that the police say went too far.
Where the behaviour is aimed at a particular person, or happens in private, the Crown is more likely to use section 38. Where there is violence, an assault charge may be added.
Defending a breach of the peace charge
- The test is not met. The conduct may have been unpleasant but not serious enough to threaten disturbance to the community.
- No public element. If the conduct happened in private, breach of the peace may be the wrong charge.
- Identification and evidence. Busy scenes and late nights make mistakes more likely. We examine CCTV and witness evidence closely.
- Alternatives to prosecution. For a first or minor incident, we can ask the fiscal to deal with the case by a warning, fiscal fine or diversion.
Penalties
Breach of the peace is usually prosecuted in the justice of the peace court or the sheriff court as a summary case. Common outcomes are an admonition, a fine or a community payback order. More serious cases, especially those with aggravations such as prejudice, can attract heavier sentences.
Criminal defence fees
We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.
Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.
Book a free consultation

