Threatening or abusive behaviour, often called a "section 38" charge, is one of the most frequently prosecuted offences in Scotland. It can arise from an argument in the street, a dispute with a neighbour, a heated phone call or messages sent online. Because the offence is so broad, the details of what was said, the context and how it was perceived matter a great deal.
Our lawyers in Glasgow defend section 38 charges in the justice of the peace court, the sheriff court and, where the charge is linked to more serious allegations, on indictment.
Key points
- Section 38 of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 makes it an offence to behave in a threatening or abusive manner likely to cause a reasonable person fear or alarm.
- The Crown must prove you intended to cause fear or alarm, or were reckless as to whether it would.
- It is a defence to show that the behaviour was reasonable in the particular circumstances.
- The maximum sentence is 12 months in prison on summary conviction and 5 years on indictment.
In police custody now? Ask for a solicitor straight away. Advice while you are in police custody is free, and the police must arrange it, either from your own solicitor or a duty solicitor. Our enquiry form is not monitored around the clock, so do not wait to hear from us before asking for advice at the station.
What the Crown has to prove
Under section 38, a person commits an offence if they behave in a threatening or abusive manner, the behaviour would be likely to cause a reasonable person to suffer fear or alarm, and they intended to cause fear or alarm or were reckless as to whether it would. The behaviour can be a single act or a course of conduct, and it includes things said or communicated, not only things done. That is why calls, texts and social media posts are often charged under section 38.
The test is objective: would a reasonable person have been likely to suffer fear or alarm? Unlike breach of the peace, there is no need to prove a public element or a threat of disturbance to the community, so the charge is often used for incidents in private homes.
Defending a section 38 charge
- Reasonable behaviour. The Act provides a specific defence where the behaviour was reasonable in the particular circumstances, for example where you were protecting yourself or someone else.
- Not threatening or abusive. Heated, rude or offensive words are not always threatening or abusive in law. Context is everything.
- No intention or recklessness. We look at what you meant and what you knew, especially for messages taken out of context.
- Evidence and corroboration. Many of these cases depend on one person's account. We examine whether the evidence is sufficient and reliable.
Aggravations and related charges
A section 38 charge can be aggravated by prejudice, or by being committed against a partner or ex-partner. A domestic aggravation is recorded and taken into account in sentence; see domestic abuse. Where the behaviour is repeated and directed at one person, the Crown may charge stalking instead. Online messages can also be charged under communications legislation; see harassment.
Penalties
On summary conviction the maximum is 12 months in prison, a fine or both. On indictment it is 5 years. Most section 38 cases are dealt with summarily, and first offences often result in a fine, a community payback order or an admonition. The court can also make a non-harassment order to protect the person involved.
Criminal defence fees
We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.
Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.
Book a free consultation

