Shoplifting is one of the most common reasons people come into contact with the police for the first time. Many cases involve items of low value, a moment of poor judgement, or a genuine mistake at a self-service checkout. Even so, a conviction for dishonesty can affect your job, your studies and future criminal record checks.
Our shoplifting solicitors in Glasgow help people resolve these cases as quickly and quietly as possible, and defend them where the allegation is wrong.
Key points
- Shoplifting is charged as theft, a common law crime that needs dishonest intent.
- A genuine mistake, for example at a self-checkout, is not theft.
- First and minor offences can often be dealt with by a Recorded Police Warning, a fiscal fine or diversion, which are not convictions.
- Store CCTV and staff evidence are usually central, and both can be challenged.
In police custody now? Ask for a solicitor straight away. Advice while you are in police custody is free, and the police must arrange it, either from your own solicitor or a duty solicitor. Our enquiry form is not monitored around the clock, so do not wait to hear from us before asking for advice at the station.
How shoplifting cases are dealt with
After an incident, store staff or security usually call the police. You may be dealt with on the spot by a Recorded Police Warning or a fixed penalty, reported to the procurator fiscal, or arrested. If you are reported, the fiscal may offer an alternative to prosecution, such as a fiscal fine, fiscal work order or diversion to a support service, or decide to prosecute in the justice of the peace court or sheriff court.
We can write to the fiscal on your behalf, setting out your circumstances and asking for the case to be dealt with without a prosecution. This is often the most effective step in a first-offence case.
Self-checkout mistakes
Self-service tills have led to many allegations against people who never meant to steal: an item not scanning, a multi-buy offer misread, or a bag forgotten in the trolley. The Crown must prove dishonest intent. If you made a genuine mistake, take advice before any police interview so that your explanation is clear and consistent.
Defending a shoplifting charge
- No dishonest intent: a mistake, distraction or misunderstanding is not theft.
- Identification: store CCTV is often poor quality, and staff may be mistaken.
- Insufficient evidence: the Crown generally needs corroboration, such as CCTV supporting a witness.
- Mitigation: where an offence is admitted, personal circumstances such as financial hardship, health or addiction can strongly affect the outcome.
If force or threats were used to get away, the charge may become robbery. If someone is accused of buying the goods afterwards, see handling stolen goods.
Penalties for shoplifting
Most shoplifting cases end with an alternative to prosecution, or, if prosecuted, a fine, compensation order or community sentence. Repeated offending or high-value thefts can lead to prison. Read more on theft charges.
Criminal defence fees
We act in criminal cases on a private fee basis and do not provide criminal legal aid. Before any work starts we explain how our fees are worked out and confirm an estimate in writing. Advice in police custody is free whoever provides it. See our criminal defence services for more about how we work.
Under investigation or charged? Get confidential advice from our criminal defence team. The first hour is free.
Book a free consultation

