
Pleading guilty is one of the most important decisions in a criminal case, and some people regret it almost immediately. They may feel they were rushed, did not understand the charge, or were wrongly advised. In Scotland, it is possible to withdraw a guilty plea, but only in exceptional circumstances.
The courts treat a guilty plea as a solemn admission. Changing your mind, or being unhappy with the likely sentence, is not enough on its own. Acting quickly, and getting independent advice, gives you the best chance.
Key points
- A guilty plea can only be withdrawn in exceptional circumstances.
- The courts have recognised real error or misconception, or circumstances clearly prejudicial to the accused, as examples.
- Before sentence, an application can be made to the court that accepted the plea.
- After sentence, the route is usually an appeal on the ground of a miscarriage of justice.
- Changing from not guilty to guilty is much easier and can attract a sentence discount.
The test for withdrawing a guilty plea
The leading authority is Healy v HM Advocate (1990), which has been applied in many later appeals. A guilty plea may be withdrawn only in exceptional circumstances, for example where it was tendered under a real error or misconception, or in circumstances that were clearly prejudicial to the accused.
Examples of situations that may be relevant include:
- you did not understand the charge you were pleading to, or a key part of it;
- the plea was tendered without your clear instructions;
- you were given fundamentally wrong advice about the law or the evidence;
- a health condition meant you could not properly understand or decide;
- important information about the evidence was not available to you when you pleaded.
Situations that are usually not enough include simply changing your mind, regretting the decision once you learn the likely sentence, or feeling under ordinary pressure at court.
Before sentence
If you have pleaded guilty and the court has deferred sentence, for example for reports, an application to withdraw the plea can be made before sentence is imposed. The court will need a clear explanation, often supported by evidence, of why the plea was tendered and why it should be withdrawn.
Good to know: If your concern is about the advice you received, you will usually need a new solicitor, because your original solicitor may become a witness. See changing your criminal defence solicitor.
After sentence
Once you have been sentenced, the usual route is an appeal against conviction on the ground that there has been a miscarriage of justice. Strict time limits apply.
| Type of case | Time limit to begin an appeal against conviction |
|---|---|
| Solemn (jury) cases | Intimation of intention to appeal within 2 weeks of the final decision |
| Summary cases | Application for a stated case within 1 week of the final decision |
Late appeals can sometimes be allowed, but you should not rely on that. See our criminal appeal lawyers for how appeals work, and our guide on appealing a sentence after a guilty plea if your concern is the sentence rather than the conviction.
What should I do now?
- Act immediately The earlier you raise the issue, the better, especially before sentence.
- Write down what happened Note what you were told, when and by whom, and why you pleaded guilty.
- Gather evidence Medical records, messages and any documents about the advice you received can all matter.
- Get independent advice A solicitor who was not involved in your plea can assess whether the test is likely to be met.
Changing a not guilty plea to guilty
Changing a not guilty plea to guilty is straightforward and can be done at any stage. Courts in Scotland must take into account the timing of a guilty plea when sentencing, and an earlier plea can lead to a lower sentence. Our court representation and sheriff court solicitors advise on plea at every stage.
Regret your guilty plea? Get urgent, independent advice from our criminal defence team. Your first hour is free.
Book a free consultationFrequently asked questions
Can I withdraw a guilty plea because the sentence was too harsh?
No. Unhappiness with the sentence is not a reason to withdraw a plea. You may be able to appeal against the sentence instead.
Can I withdraw a guilty plea if my solicitor pressured me?
Ordinary firm advice is not enough. If the plea was tendered without your proper instructions, or the advice was fundamentally wrong, that may be relevant.
What happens if the court lets me withdraw my plea?
The conviction based on the plea is set aside and the case usually proceeds as if you had pleaded not guilty, which can lead to a trial.
Is there a deadline to withdraw a guilty plea?
Before sentence, there is no fixed deadline, but delay weakens the application. After sentence, appeal time limits apply.



