
Yes. Pleading guilty means you accept that you committed the offence, but it does not mean you have to accept whatever sentence the court imposes. You can appeal against a sentence you believe was excessive or wrong in principle, even after a guilty plea.
The time limits are very short, though. In summary cases you have just 1 week from sentence, and in solemn cases 2 weeks. Getting advice immediately is essential.
Key points
- You can appeal a sentence after pleading guilty.
- In summary cases, a note of appeal against sentence must be lodged within 1 week of the sentence.
- In solemn cases, a note of appeal against sentence alone must be lodged within 2 weeks.
- Courts must take account of the timing of a guilty plea when sentencing, and failing to give proper credit can be a ground of appeal.
- On some appeals, the appeal court can substitute a more severe sentence, so take advice on the risks first.
What are the grounds for a sentence appeal?
The appeal court does not simply ask whether it would have chosen a different sentence. The question is usually whether the sentence was excessive, or wrong in principle. Common grounds include:
- the sentence was excessive for the offence and your circumstances;
- the court did not give proper credit for your guilty plea;
- the court did not give enough weight to mitigation, such as your background, health, employment or caring responsibilities;
- the court took account of something it should not have, or got the facts wrong;
- a community sentence should have been imposed instead of custody;
- an associated order, such as a driving disqualification or compensation order, was wrong.
The guilty plea discount
Under section 196 of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995, a court sentencing someone who pleaded guilty must take into account the stage at which the plea was tendered and the circumstances in which it was given. An earlier plea usually earns a greater reduction. If the court gives no discount, or a reduced one, it should explain why.
Failing to apply the discount properly, or giving inadequate reasons, can be a strong ground of appeal.
Time limits
| Type of case | Time limit for a sentence appeal | Heard by |
|---|---|---|
| Summary (sheriff or justice of the peace, no jury) | 1 week from sentence | Sheriff Appeal Court |
| Solemn in the sheriff court | 2 weeks from sentence | Sheriff Appeal Court |
| Solemn in the High Court | 2 weeks from sentence | High Court of Justiciary |
Late appeals can sometimes be allowed, but an extension is not guaranteed. If you think you might want to appeal, speak to a solicitor the same day if possible.
How a sentence appeal works
- Review A solicitor reviews the sentencing remarks, the reports and the plea in mitigation.
- Note of appeal The note is lodged within the time limit, setting out the grounds.
- Leave to appeal A judge or sheriff decides whether the appeal has arguable grounds to proceed.
- Interim liberation If you are in custody, an application can be made for bail pending the appeal.
- The hearing The appeal court decides whether to refuse the appeal or quash the sentence and impose another.
Good to know: If your appeal concerns a driving ban, you may be able to ask for the ban to be suspended while the appeal is decided. Ask about this straight away.
What are the risks?
On some appeals, the appeal court has power to quash a sentence and substitute another, which can in principle be more severe. Separately, the Crown can appeal a sentence it considers unduly lenient. A solicitor can advise whether an appeal is realistic and what the risks are before anything is lodged.
If your concern is that you should not have pleaded guilty at all, that is a different question. See can I change my plea from guilty to not guilty and our criminal appeal lawyers.
Can a different solicitor handle my appeal?
Yes. Many people instruct a new solicitor for an appeal, especially if they want a fresh view. See changing your criminal defence solicitor. Our sentence appeal solicitors act in appeals from the sheriff court and the High Court.
Unhappy with your sentence? The deadline could be days away. Contact our criminal defence team now. Your first hour is free.
Book a free consultationFrequently asked questions
Does pleading guilty stop me appealing?
It stops you appealing against conviction in most cases, but not against sentence.
How long does a sentence appeal take?
It varies. Leave to appeal is usually decided within weeks, and a full hearing can follow some weeks or months later.
Can my sentence be reduced if my circumstances have changed?
New information about your circumstances since sentence can sometimes be put before the appeal court, such as health or employment changes.
Can I appeal a community payback order?
Yes. A community payback order is a sentence and can be appealed in the same way, within the same time limits.



