Legal guide

What Happens at a Benefit Fraud Interview Under Caution in Scotland?

Published

A letter inviting you to an "interview under caution" about your benefits is worrying, and it is meant to be taken seriously. It means investigators suspect benefit fraud and want to put that suspicion to you in a formal interview that can be used as evidence.

In Scotland, the interview is carried out either by the Department for Work and Pensions, for UK benefits such as Universal Credit, or by Social Security Scotland, for Scottish benefits such as Adult Disability Payment. Either way, if fraud is suspected, the case can be reported to the procurator fiscal for prosecution.

Key points

  • An interview under caution means anything you say can be used as evidence if you are prosecuted.
  • You do not have to attend, and you do not have to answer questions.
  • The interview is recorded.
  • You can have a solicitor with you, and you can ask to speak to one at any time during the interview.
  • Repaying an overpayment and being prosecuted for fraud are separate processes.

Who carries out the interview?

BenefitInvestigated byMain legislation
UK benefits, such as Universal Credit, Pension Credit and Personal Independence PaymentDepartment for Work and PensionsSocial Security Administration Act 1992
Scottish benefits, such as Adult Disability Payment, Child Disability Payment and Scottish Child PaymentSocial Security Scotland counter fraud officersSocial Security (Scotland) Act 2018
Council Tax ReductionYour local councilVaries with the case

In Scotland, whichever body investigates, the decision to prosecute is made by the procurator fiscal.

What happens before the interview?

You will not usually know at first that you are being investigated. Investigators gather information, which can include bank records, employer details and other data, before inviting you to interview. An investigation can relate to events several years earlier.

The invitation letter will tell you the date, time and place, and that the interview is under caution. Contact a solicitor as soon as you receive it.

What happens during the interview?

  1. The caution You are told you do not have to say anything, but that what you do say may be used in evidence.
  2. Your rights You are reminded that you can have a solicitor and can stop the interview to take advice.
  3. The questions The investigator asks about your claim, your circumstances and the evidence they have gathered, such as earnings or living arrangements.
  4. Your account You can explain what happened, provide documents, or decline to answer.
  5. The end of the interview You are told what happens next. Decisions are not usually made on the day.

Good to know: If you have a disability, a mental health condition or difficulty understanding, tell the investigators in advance. Adjustments, such as having a supporter present, may be needed.

Should you attend and answer questions?

You do not have to attend. If you do not, the investigation will usually continue without your explanation. Whether to attend, and whether to answer questions, give a prepared statement or say nothing, depends on the evidence and your explanation. Many people have a genuine explanation, such as a misunderstanding about what had to be reported, and the interview may be the chance to give it. Others are better advised to say nothing until they have seen the evidence.

Our benefit fraud solicitors and interview solicitors can advise on the best approach before you go.

What happens afterwards?

  • No evidence of fraud. The case is closed.
  • Overpayment. A decision maker decides whether benefit was overpaid and whether you must repay it. You can challenge that decision.
  • Report to the fiscal. If fraud is suspected, the case can be reported to the procurator fiscal, who decides whether to prosecute.

Prosecutions can be brought under benefit legislation or as common law fraud. The most serious statutory offence of dishonestly making a false statement under the 1992 Act carries up to 7 years in prison on indictment. Many cases are dealt with in the sheriff court.

Invited to an interview under caution? Speak to our criminal defence team before you attend. Your first hour is free.

Book a free consultation

Frequently asked questions

Can I bring someone to a benefit fraud interview?

Yes. You can bring a solicitor, and you may be able to bring a friend, relative or advocate for support.

Will I be arrested at a benefit fraud interview?

Benefit investigators are not police officers and the interview is usually voluntary. In some cases, the police may be involved separately.

If I repay the money, will I avoid prosecution?

Not necessarily. Repayment is separate from the decision to prosecute, although it can be relevant to that decision and to sentence.

Can I be prosecuted years later?

Yes. There is no general time limit for prosecuting serious benefit fraud, and investigations often look back several years.

More from our legal blog

Book your free consultation